PROOF OF USEFULNESS

The validation system that measures what matters: real utility instead of vibe coded beauty, technical sophistication, or pitchdeck projections. HackerNoon's Proof of Usefulness evaluates human, financial and technical adoption and value creation. Is it good? Do people use it? A technical approach to answering these simple questions.

Submissions open in

Days

Hours

Minutes

Seconds

Rolling Submissions: January 5th - June 5th, 2026

Winners Announced Monthly | Final Awards: June-July 2026

The Problem vs The Solution

We're drowning in style over substance, while real people need real tools.

The AI Vibe Decay Problem

Style over substance everywhere

Beautiful apps with no users

Pitch decks for products that don't exist

Vaporware funded because of alma mater clout and TikTok charisma

MVPs that launch, then vanish

Meanwhile, real people need real tools.

The Solution

Measure what actually matters

The world needs tools, not another pitch deck.

Usefulness is how ideas grow.

Usage is the new valuation

No one remembers what was promised. Everyone remembers what worked.

Proof of Usefulness rewards real impact.

Free Credits to Build Something Useful

Our sponsors are offering free credits to help you build. Claim yours and start creating with enterprise-grade tools.

$250

In Free Credits

Bright Data is the leading web data infrastructure company, empowering over 20,000 organizations with ethical, scalable access to real-time public web information. From startups to industry leaders, we deliver the datasets that fuel AI innovation and real-world impact. Ready to unlock the web?

Claim Credits

$540

45-days Growth+ Plan Access

Storyblok is a headless CMS built for developers who want clean architecture and full control. Structure your content once, connect it anywhere, and keep your front end truly independent. API-first. AI-ready. Framework-agnostic. Future-proof.

Claim Credits

AuraDB

Free For All

Neo4j is the graph intelligence platform that transforms data into knowledge to power the next generation of intelligent applications and AI systems. Trusted by 84 of the Fortune 100, Neo4j enables accurate, explainable, and governed AI through its enterprise-ready graph database and analytics capabilities across any environment or data source.

Claim Credits

Build Tier

Free For All

Algolia provides a managed retrieval layer that lets developers quickly build web search and intelligent AI agents. Built for speed, relevance, and scale, Algolia handles indexing, ranking, semantic understanding, and vector search so teams can focus on building great experiences. With products like AI Search, Agent Studio, and AI Recommendations, it delivers real-time updates and instant results out of the box. Whether you’re powering e-commerce, SaaS, or AI-driven apps, Algolia makes retrieval fast, reliable, and easy to integrate.

Claim Credits

David Smooke

Founder & CEO, HackerNoon

Proof of Usefulness is about cutting through the noise and measuring what actually matters: does your project solve real problems for real people? It's time we reward utility over hype.

The Proof of Usefulness Algorithm

Bitcoin's proof-of-work requires miners to solve cryptographic puzzles, consuming massive energy to validate transactions. Our proof-of-usefulness requires projects to solve real problems for actual users.

Instead of hash rates and mining difficulty, we measure user adoption, revenue sustainability, technical stability, and genuine utility. Projects are scored from -100 to +1000 based on empirical evidence, with seven distinct tiers:

751-1000:Unicorn Utility - Product has undeniable utility and massive adoption.
601-750:Category Standard - Product is a default choice and trusted across its category.
451-600:Industry Mainstay - Product is a definitive solution to a market problem.
301-450:Certified Problem Solver - Product is self-sustaining and provide long-term operational stability
101-300:Gaining Momentum - Product is officially moving from "neat idea" to "serious contender"
0-100:You're In Business - You’ve hit "Deploy" and the world didn't crash.
(-100)-0:Lab Mode - Product is almost ready for the big reveal

The algorithm cross-validates responses against publicly available data, ensuring projects can't simply claim utility without demonstrating it.

calculateUsefulness()

function calculateUsefulness(project) {

let baseScore = 0;

let qualityMultipliers = [];

// Evidence depth analysis

const responseQuality = analyzeResponseDepth(project.responses);

const quantitativeEvidence = extractMetrics(project.responses);

const crossValidation = validateAgainstPublicData(project.url);

// Core utility scoring

for (const criterion of UTILITY_CRITERIA) {

const rawScore = evaluateCriterion(criterion, project);

const qualityFactor = responseQuality[criterion.name];

const validationFactor = crossValidation[criterion.name];

const adjustedScore = rawScore * qualityFactor * validationFactor;

baseScore += criterion.weight * adjustedScore;

}

return Math.clamp(baseScore, -1000, 1000);

}

Core Algorithm

PoU_score = Σ_i=1ⁿ (w_i × C_i × Q_i) + R_factor

The Proof of Usefulness score aggregates weighted criterion scores, adjusted by response quality factors and cross-validation results, with a randomization component to account for market uncertainty and prevent gaming.

w_i

Weight Factor

Statistical weight based on correlation analysis of 500+ successful projects

C_i

Criterion Score

Normalized score from response analysis and evidence validation

Q_i

Quality Factor

Response quality multiplier based on depth and specificity

R_factor

Randomization

Market uncertainty component (±20% variance)

Weight Distribution

Criterion	Weight	Correlation	Justification
User Adoption	20%	r = 0.847	Strongest predictor of sustainability
Revenue Generation	18%	r = 0.792	Indicates genuine value creation
Internet Necessity	17%	r = 0.734	Differentiates from redundant solutions
Technical Stability	15%	r = 0.681	Required for sustained usage
Functional Completeness	15%	r = 0.667	Core features must work reliably
Stakeholder Value	15%	r = 0.643	Ecosystem benefit assessment

Proof of Usefulness Validation Criteria

Six comprehensive criteria determine utility, each requiring evidence that demonstrates genuine value creation and sustainable operation.

User Adoption

Real users engaging with your product, not just wallet addresses holding tokens or demo day attendees.

Weight: 20%

Revenue Generation

Sustainable income from value creation, not speculative trading fees or "monetization coming soon" promises.

Weight: 18%

Internet Necessity

Solving problems that matter, not just distributed Sudoku puzzles or blockchain solutions seeking problems.

Weight: 17%

Technical Stability

Reliable infrastructure without burning coal for consensus or requiring constant developer intervention.

Weight: 15%

Functional Completeness

Features that work as advertised, validated by usage not mining pools or demo videos.

Weight: 15%

Stakeholder Value

Clear benefits for participants beyond hodling and hoping for token appreciation.

Weight: 15%

See How Major Brands Score

From tech giants to startups, see real Proof of Usefulness scores based on actual utility metrics

Loading featured projects...

View All Reports

Ready to Measure Your Project's Real Impact?

Get your Proof of Usefulness score and compete for $100k in prizes

Free evaluation Instant results $100k in prizes

Coming Soon

PROOF OF USEFULNESS

Sponsored by

Rewarding projects under these HackerNoon tech tags:

The Problem vs The Solution

The AI Vibe Decay Problem

The Solution

Free Credits to Build Something Useful

The Proof of Usefulness Algorithm

Weight Distribution

Proof of Usefulness Validation Criteria

User Adoption

Revenue Generation

Internet Necessity

Technical Stability

Functional Completeness

Stakeholder Value

See How Major Brands Score

Ready to Measure Your Project's Real Impact?